The Hidden Costs of Overtime in Finance & Accounting Teams

When financial and accounting deadlines loom (like closing the books, preparing for an audit, or managing benefits enrollment), overtime can feel like the easiest way to keep projects moving. Asking your team to put in longer hours may provide a short-term boost, but the hidden costs of this approach can far outweigh the benefits.

From reduced productivity to compliance risks and rising turnover, leaders who rely too heavily on overtime risk damaging both performance and morale. The smartest organizations are finding better ways to meet deadlines without pushing their people past their limits.

Why Overtime Isn’t the Answer

Productivity Drops Sharply

Research from Stanford University shows that productivity per hour declines significantly once employees pass 50 hours per week. After 55 hours, output falls so dramatically that additional time contributes almost no value.

For accounting and finance teams responsible for precise reconciliations, accurate reporting, and strict compliance, this means that each extra hour may be less effective, and more dangerous, than you think.

Errors Increase Under Fatigue

Accounting and finance require sustained focus. When professionals are tired, their ability to catch errors plummets. Even small mistakes can create ripple effects: reconciliations that don’t balance, reports that need rework, or compliance issues that raise red flags in an audit.

One survey found that 85% of accounting teams had to reopen closed books to correct mistakes, often multiple times per year. Fatigue was a leading factor.

Burnout and Turnover Rise

Burnout is already high in finance and accounting roles. Deloitte research shows that 77% of professionals have experienced burnout in their current position. Extended overtime accelerates this trend, driving your most valuable employees to search for less stressful roles.

Replacing skilled talent is costly, up to 30% of an employee’s annual salary, according to the U.S. Department of Labor. Losing key staff during a fiscal close or audit can disrupt operations and morale.

Why Overtime Hits Industries Differently

Although overtime is a universal risk, the effects vary by industry:

• Healthcare: Accounting staff in hospitals and health systems often manage multiple funding sources, complex compliance regulations, and heavy patient volume data. Errors caused by fatigue can jeopardize reimbursements or delay critical funding. 
• Manufacturing & Distribution: These industries run on tight margins. When financial reporting is delayed due to overworked staff, leaders lack the insights they need to make timely production or supply chain decisions. 
• Retail: High transaction volumes, seasonal sales cycles, and frequent inventory reconciliations create unique demands on finance and accounting teams. Excessive overtime during peak periods like holiday seasons or quarterly closes increases the risk of miscounted revenue, inaccurate reporting, and compliance gaps that can ripple across the entire organization. 
• Construction & Property Management: These sectors are project-driven and deadline-intensive. Accounting and finance teams must track budgets, manage subcontractor payments, and reconcile project costs in real time. Overtime fatigue can lead to billing errors, delayed draws, or inaccurate cost reporting that puts projects and client trust at risk. 
• Education: School systems, universities, and training institutions operate within strict funding cycles and compliance frameworks. During fiscal year-end or federal reporting periods, overtime fatigue can result in missed deadlines, errors in grant tracking, or compliance issues that jeopardize future funding. 
• Nonprofits: Limited budgets mean these organizations cannot afford premium last-minute hiring costs. Relying on overtime not only risks compliance with funder requirements but can also quickly erode morale in mission-driven teams.

In every sector, overtime fatigue doesn’t just threaten the finance team; it ripples through the entire organization.

Warning Signs Your Team Is Reaching the Breaking Point

Before burnout and mistakes derail performance, watch for these indicators:

• Increased absenteeism or sick days
• Declining morale or disengagement
• More frequent corrections or rework
• Key staff openly discussing job searches

If you’re seeing these signals, it’s time to adjust workload strategies before it’s too late.

Smarter Staffing Strategies to Reduce Overtime

Preventing overtime fatigue doesn’t mean avoiding extra hours altogether; it means using them strategically and supporting your team with additional resources during peak periods.

Here are advanced strategies to keep your workforce strong:

1. Forecast with Precision

Go beyond basic calendars. Use historical close data, workload trends, and upcoming project forecasts to predict pressure points months in advance. Leaders who plan proactively can request support early, securing the best talent before the market tightens.

2. Build a “Surge Capacity” Model

Create a flexible staffing plan that includes both permanent employees and pre-vetted contractors who can be deployed quickly. For example, keep a bench of payroll specialists for benefits cycles and AR/AP experts for quarter-end.

3. Rotate & Rebalance Workloads

Instead of loading the same employees with recurring high-stress assignments, rotate responsibilities across the team. Temporary staff can be trained to handle repeatable processes—such as reconciliations or benefits enrollment tasks—so core staff can focus on high-value analysis and compliance.

4. Leverage Technology + Staffing Mix

Automation tools can help with routine tasks like invoice matching or basic reconciliations, but they don’t replace the need for skilled staff. The most successful finance and accounting teams pair technology with contract professionals who bring expertise in ERP systems, data validation, or compliance.

5. Prioritize Well-Being to Retain Talent

Overtime alone doesn’t cause turnover; it’s the lack of relief and recognition that pushes people out. Provide mental health resources, flexible scheduling, and a clear staffing plan that shows employees their workload won’t always rest on their shoulders.

Protect Your Team—and Your Bottom Line

The financial and human costs of overtime can far exceed the expense of proactive staffing. By supplementing your core staff with pre-vetted professionals during peak times, you can:

• Deliver accurate, compliant reporting on schedule
• Maintain team engagement and reduce turnover
• Lower overtime pay and reduce costly errors
• Keep accounting and finance operations running smoothly without burning out your best people

Ready to Avoid Overtime Fatigue?

At PrideStaff Financial, we specialize in recruiting top accounting and finance professionals who can step in and make an immediate impact. Whether you need contract staff for a few weeks or long-term project support, we can help you meet critical deadlines without relying on endless overtime.

Need Finance and Accounting Talent Now?
Complete our short Request Talent form, and we’ll connect you with professionals who are vetted, experienced, and ready to help.